At first glance, Mark Zuckerberg’s Threads looked like a promising alternative to Twitter (which is now rebranded to X — RIP “Twitter”). Threads became the fastest-growing app in history. It lured over some Twitter traffic. And Elon Musk’s lawyer even threatened Zuckerberg with legal action over the “copycat” platform.
But beyond the surface-level similarities, Threads doesn’t actually want to replace Twitter (we mean X). Instead of serving as a real-time discourse forum — politics and news are no longer part of Meta’s larger brand — it’s more of a hangout space for lifestyle brands and influencers. While that might sound great to advertisers, it's hard to imagine people will want to be confined to the vapid topics that do best on Instagram, Paris Marx writes for Insider.
Even those involved in Threads seem to agree. Instagram head Adam Mosseri said (of course, via Threads) that “there are more than enough amazing communities — sports, music, fashion, beauty, entertainment, etc — to make a vibrant platform without needing to get into politics or hard news.”
That’s great for Musk’s social network. As the site gets less usable by the day, a platform gap remains for users who originally flocked to Twitter for its main selling point: relevancy.
Twitter gave real-time updates from vetted sources, mingled with opinions from average users. And this created a unique, live experience from any screen.
Many (including Twitter cofounder Jack Dorsey) have tried and failed to recreate that cacophonous online magic. Something between the user-friendliness, mass adoption, or content moderation of alternative sites like Mastodon and Bluesky has always created too large of a barrier to migrate people over from Twitter.
Between Threads not seeking to fill that role and Twitter’s slow decline, people may soon lack a reliable online space to have real-time discourse. Until a platform fills the gap, users who fueled the main selling point of the former Twitter are going to continue falling through the cracks. Or, they may just go back to Twitter (rather, X).
No comments:
Post a Comment